A Superior Court judge has overturned a decision by Sherman’s Zoning Board of Appeals, calling its handling of a property use case “arbitrary” and “legally flawed.” The dispute centered on unpermitted commercial activity at land owned by Joel and Roberta Judd. Neighbor John Dwyer complained about junk, noise, and trailers, prompting a 2022 cease-and-desist order. The board partially sided with the Judds last year, but the judge ruled the board’s reasoning was confusing and invalid. The ruling forces the Judds to comply with the original order.